Are Backyard Breeders Bad? (My Experience)

The term “backyard breeder” often carries a negative connotation, but is it always deserved? In this article, we’ll delve into the world of backyard breeders and explore the pros and cons of this controversial practice. We’ll examine the ethical, legal, and health concerns associated with backyard breeding, and compare it to other options like adopting from shelters or purchasing from reputable breeders.

Moreover, we’ll also discuss the importance of responsible breeding practices for backyard chickens and other popular backyard animals.

Join us as we navigate the complexities of backyard breeding and provide you with the information you need to make informed choices.

The cruel reality of puppy mills
Backyard breeding can be harmful to animals and their offspring.
Many backyard breeders prioritize profit over animal welfare.
Adopting from a shelter or reputable breeder is a better option.
Supporting legislation to regulate breeding practices can help prevent animal cruelty.
Raising animals ethically and sustainably is possible without resorting to backyard breeding.

Are All Backyard Breeders Bad?

No, not at all. There are many good backyard breeders who are responsible and take great care of their animals. 

But there are also bad ones who don’t care about their pets and treat them like trash. It’s important to know the difference between a good backyard breeder and a bad one so you can make an informed decision when purchasing from one!

Where Do You Find Backyard Breeders?

You can find backyard breeders everywhere. You’ll find them in your local newspaper, on the internet, in local shelters and pet stores you name it. And because of their sheer number, you have to be careful when choosing a breeder.

The best place to start is with a local shelter or dog rescue group; they are usually more than willing to put you in touch with reputable breeders who will be able to give you all the information you need about buying from them instead of an unethical one.

If you’re interested in raising animals in your backyard, there are plenty of options that don’t involve harmful breeding practices. Check out our guide on 11 animals that can be raised in the backyard to learn more about ethical and sustainable ways to care for animals.

Is Breeding Dogs In Your Back Yard Illegal?

You can’t sell dogs from your back yard to pet stores, and you definitely can’t sell puppies from your back yard. 

If you’re selling a dog or puppy from your home, it needs to be done through legitimate channels you can’t just go about selling pets out of the trunk of your car like some kind of Craigslist scammer.

Pros and Cons of Adopting from a Shelter

Provides a home for animals in needMay have limited selection of breeds
Adoption fees are often lower than buying from a breederAnimals may have unknown health or behavioral issues
Shelters often provide basic medical care and spay/neuter servicesMay require additional training or behavioral interventions
Adopting a senior pet can be a rewarding experienceMay require more time and resources to care for than expected

Do Backyard Breeders Sell To Pet Stores?

Pet stores are a bad place to buy a puppy. Pet stores have no standards for the dogs they sell, so you don’t know if you’re getting a healthy puppy with good genetics. 

They don’t care about the health of their puppies or what happens to them after they leave their store (which is usually only until someone adopts them). 

Many pet stores get their puppies from backyard breeders because they can make more money selling them than an animal shelter or rescue group that would spay and neuter them for free. Plus, many backyard breeders sell directly to pet shops too!

Should I Buy A Puppy From A Breeder In My Back Yard?

If you are buying a puppy, you should buy from a responsible breeder. Responsible breeders provide their puppies with good medical care and socialization. 

They often sell directly to the public so that you can meet your new puppy’s parents and see how they live. They will tell you about any health problems in the breed so that you can make an informed decision on whether or not this is the right dog for you.

Curious about the legal implications of backyard breeding? Our guide on are backyard breeders illegal explained breaks down the various laws and regulations surrounding backyard breeding practices.

Best Practices for Ethical Animal Breeding

Best Practices
Prioritize animal welfare over profit
Ensure animals have access to proper medical care
Only breed animals with desirable traits and characteristics
Avoid inbreeding and genetic defects
Screen potential buyers to ensure animals go to good homes
Maintain proper living conditions and socialization for animals
Support legislation to regulate breeding practices

Do Backyard Breeders Care Less About The Dogs They Produce?

Backyard breeders are not concerned with the welfare of the dogs they produce. They only care about making money and will therefore sell a puppy to anyone who has enough cash to pay for it. 

Backyard breeders do not screen potential owners or ask them about their lifestyle, so many times backyard-bred dogs end up in homes that cannot adequately care for them.

Backyard breeders also don’t seem to care about health issues that may be passed down from generations of breeding. The puppies produced by these breeders are often unhealthy due to genetic defects and poorer living conditions than those at reputable breeders’ facilities.

What Is The Difference Between A Backyard Breeder And A Puppy Mill?

Backyard breeders and puppy mills are two sides of the same coin. They both have too many animals, with poor living conditions and breeding practices. There are only two differences between them:

  • A backyard breeder is an amateur who sells dogs on their own. A puppy mill is a commercial operation that sells dogs through pet stores or online.
  • A backyard breeder doesn’t make his or her living from selling dogs they do it for fun and profit, just as you might sell something you made in your spare time at craft fairs or flea markets (or whatever). 

Puppy mills are focused on turning a profit by breeding as many puppies as possible regardless of health consequences or temperament problems they cause in later generations.

Backyard dog breeding can have serious health and ethical consequences for both the animals and their future owners. Learn more about why backyard dog breeders are harmful in our guide on are backyard dog breeders bad.

Why Are Puppies So Expensive Now?

There are several reasons why puppies are so expensive. The first is that the breed itself is very popular and in high demand, which means more people are willing to pay for it. 

Plus, since these dogs have become very popular, there are now many backyard breeders who want to cash in on the trend as quickly as possible.

The second reason is that some unscrupulous breeders sell their puppies at an excessive price because they know that most people will buy whatever they can afford regardless of how much they spend or what kind of conditions their home could be living in if the dog was not cared for properly by someone else

How Do You Know If You Are Dealing With A Backyard Breeder Or An Ethical Breeder?

The following questions can help you determine if you are dealing with a backyard breeder or an ethical breeder.

  • Ask for pedigree papers, which should be signed by the breeder and include the names of all dogs in their lineage.
  • Ask for a health guarantee that covers genetic defects, congenital problems (present at birth), and overall health concerns. A good contract should allow you to return your puppy if something isn’t right or doesn’t work out within a certain time frame (two weeks is standard). 

The seller may require that you pay for shipping back to them, but this is a standard practice among reputable breeders it’s their way of ensuring that they don’t get stuck with sick or dying puppies from uncooperative buyers who just want to return them without having a valid reason for doing so.

While keeping backyard chickens can be a fun and rewarding experience, it’s important to be aware of the potential health risks associated with them. Check out our guide on are backyard chickens dangerous to learn more about how to keep yourself and your chickens healthy.

What Causes The Problems With Puppy Mills And Backyard Breeders?

You may be wondering what causes the problems with puppy mills and backyard breeders. The answer is simple: a lack of regulation, knowledge, care, concern, love, and responsibility. 

So long as there are no regulations in place to ensure that the dogs are healthy, treated well, and bred responsibly, then there will always be tragedies like Puppy Doe or the story of Barbie’s puppies.


In conclusion, it is important to know that there are ethical breeders and puppy mills. Many backyard breeders care about the dogs they produce. 

However, this does not mean that all backyard breeders are good people or that we should automatically trust them with our money and pets. 

There are many reasons why you would want to stay away from these types of breeders in your own backyard, including health problems and poor living conditions for their dogs. Therefore always do research before purchasing any new pet or animal products!

Looking to transform your backyard space but not sure where to start? Our guide on how do you start landscaping your backyard has everything you need to know, from planning to execution, to create a beautiful and functional outdoor space

Further Reading

14 Alternatives to Grass Backyard and Why You Should Care: This article provides alternatives to traditional grass lawns and explains why they may be better for the environment and your wallet.

Are Backyard Chicken Eggs Safe to Eat?: This article addresses common questions and concerns about the safety of eating eggs from backyard chickens, including the risk of salmonella.

How Much Does it Cost to Fully Landscape a Backyard?: This article provides a breakdown of the costs associated with fully landscaping a backyard, including materials, labor, and design fees.

How Do You Hang Lights in a Backyard Globe?: This article offers a step-by-step guide for hanging lights in backyard globes, including tips for selecting the right lights and ensuring they are hung safely.

How Deep to Bury a Dog in Your Backyard?: This article provides guidance on how deep to bury a deceased pet in your backyard, as well as other considerations to keep in mind.

Are Dog Breeders Bad?: This article from PETA discusses the ethical concerns associated with dog breeding and why adopting from a shelter is a better option.

Signs of a Bad Breeder: The Spruce Pets outlines the signs to look for when trying to identify a bad breeder, including health concerns and unethical practices.

The Real Dangers of Backyard Breeding: This blog post from Lugar K9 Training discusses the many risks associated with backyard breeding, including health issues and overpopulation.


What is backyard breeding?

Backyard breeding is the practice of breeding animals, typically dogs, in a backyard setting without proper knowledge, training, or resources. This can lead to a variety of issues, including health problems for the animals and overpopulation.

Why is backyard breeding bad?

Backyard breeding is generally considered bad because it can lead to a number of negative outcomes for both the animals and the breed as a whole.

Backyard breeders often lack the knowledge and resources to properly care for their animals, which can result in health problems and behavioral issues. Additionally, backyard breeding can contribute to overpopulation, which can lead to overcrowding in shelters and euthanasia of unwanted animals.

Are backyard chickens a good idea?

Backyard chickens can be a great addition to a home garden, as they provide fresh eggs and can help control pests.

However, it’s important to do your research and ensure that you have the resources and knowledge to care for them properly. Additionally, some cities and homeowners associations have regulations regarding backyard chickens, so it’s important to check with your local government before getting started.