Are Backyard Breeders Good? (Explained) 

The debate around backyard breeding often raises the question: can backyard breeders be good? In this in-depth analysis, we’ll explore the potential benefits of responsible backyard breeding and discuss the factors that can contribute to positive outcomes for both the animals and their owners.

We’ll also touch on related backyard topics, such as the safety of backyard chicken eggs and the health benefits of aquaponics.

Join us as we delve into the nuances of backyard breeding and discover the potential for good when approached with care and responsibility.

The harsh reality of ‘backyard breeding
Backyard breeding can lead to health and behavioral issues for animals
Backyard breeders may prioritize profits over animal welfare
Adopting from a shelter or reputable breeder can be a better option than purchasing from a backyard breeder
Educating yourself and others on the consequences of backyard breeding can help prevent the perpetuation of this unethical practice

What Is The Difference Between A Breeder And A Puppy Mill?

When you buy a dog from a backyard breeder, you can rest assured that the puppy’s parents were well cared for. 

These dogs are part of large families and have plenty of room to roam around and play with each other. They receive regular vet care and are kept on a healthy diet of high-quality food.

By contrast, when you buy from a puppy mill or commercial kennel, there is little oversight as far as animal welfare goes. The animals live in small cages with little stimulation or socialization from other pets or humans. 

They’re often exposed to harsh lighting conditions that may cause eye damage or blindness later in life; many suffer from infections due to unsanitary living conditions; 

Most have never been groomed before being shipped out; some don’t even receive vaccinations against common diseases like distemper!

Puppy mills are not regulated by the government because they usually operate without licenses or permits they’re what we call “backyard breeders” because they don’t meet any standards whatsoever except those set by themselves (and sometimes not even then).

Backyard breeding can have negative impacts on the health and welfare of animals. To learn more about why backyard breeding is harmful, check out our article on why backyard breeders are bad and the consequences that come with it.

How to Recognize a Reputable Breeder

Characteristics of a reputable breeder
Conducts health and genetic testing on breeding animals
Provides documentation of the animal’s lineage and medical history
Allows potential owners to visit and interact with the animals
Provides ongoing support and guidance
Does not sell animals to pet stores or brokers

What’s Wrong With Buying A Puppy From A Pet Store?

Buying a puppy from a pet store is often an impulse buy. The pet store owner may try to convince you that getting your new puppy from them is better than adopting one from a shelter or rescue organization, but it’s not true. 

If you see puppies in the window of a retail store, they came from somewhere else likely a puppy mill.

Pet stores can be deceptive in their marketing tactics and what they say about their animals’ origins. Many times the puppies are sold before they are even weaned off their mother’s milk, making it difficult for them to receive proper nutrition during this critical time of development.

Why Is It Important To Find A Responsible Breeder?

If you’re looking to buy a dog, it’s important to find a responsible breeder. A reputable breeder will take the time to ensure that the puppies are being raised in a healthy environment and have been well-socialized before being sold. 

This ensures that each puppy is happy, healthy, and ready for its new home.

Why Is It Important?

When you purchase a puppy from a responsible breeder, you can be sure that the animal was bred responsibly and by someone who cares about the breed. 

Not only does this mean your pup will likely have better health than one born from backyard breeders or pet stores (where standards are often very low), but it also means he/she has been kept safe during gestation and after birth through careful supervision by his/her caretaker(s).

If you’re interested in raising animals in your backyard without the need for breeding, check out our article on 11 animals that can be raised in the backyard. We provide a list of animals that can thrive in a backyard environment and the benefits they offer.

Do I Need To See Where The Dogs Are Raised And Kept?

There are several things you should look for when you visit a breeder in person. 

These include seeing the place where they raise and keep their dogs, seeing how they interact with other animals and humans, seeing how healthy they look, and checking out their pedigree information.

You should also make sure that you can see where the dog was raised and kept because this will help you determine if it was treated well or if it lived in poor conditions. 

For example, some backyard breeders keep their dogs outside in a pen all day without any shelter from the weather or other animals who may harm them. 

This kind of treatment can cause behavioral issues later on down the road if it happens too often throughout their life span (which could be as long as 20 years).

Raising backyard chickens is a great alternative to backyard breeding, and it’s also good for the environment. Check out our article on why backyard chickens are good for the environment to learn more about the benefits of having chickens in your backyard.

How Many Litters Should My Potential Breeder Have?

If you’re looking to buy a puppy from a backyard breeder, the first thing you need to ask them is how many litters have they had over the last few years.

At least one litter in the last 2 years. Having just one litter in the last two years is ideal because it means that your breeder has been actively breeding for at least two years and has been successful in raising healthy puppies who were able to live long and happy lives.

At least one litter in the last 3 years. Any more than three years and you may be dealing with an inexperienced breeder who doesn’t know how to properly care for their animals or ensure they will be healthy when they grow up and provide puppies for sale later on down the line why should anyone trust those puppies then?

Why Do Breeders’ Fees Vary So Much?

Many factors determine how much you’ll pay for a puppy. Here are the most important:

The breeders’ reputation: The more reputable a breeder is, the more you can expect to pay for their puppies. Reputable breeders are generally concerned with providing healthy dogs, ensuring their puppies have good temperaments and socialization skills and screening them for genetic health problems. 

They also care about how well they match up potential owners with appropriate breeds and individual dogs. This means they charge more because they spend more time vetting potential owners before giving away any of their puppies (or adult dogs!). 

If you’ve got an expensive breed like a Chihuahua or a labrador retriever that comes with a lot of health problems (like allergies or hypothyroidism).

Then it makes sense to buy from someone who specializes in that particular breed that way you’ll know your dog will be healthier than average!

Location: Where your breeder lives matters too! If they live nearby then there are no shipping costs involved which means lower prices overall since it wouldn’t make financial sense otherwise since shipping costs so much money per mile traveled! 

That being said though sometimes even local ones may still seem expensive due to other factors such as reputation which we covered above; 

But if yours isn’t too far away then go ahead and give them a try just to make sure not to sign any papers until after meeting face-to-face first – just in case something goes wrong later on down the road!

Do All Breeders Guarantee Their Puppies?

If a breeder does not guarantee their puppies, it’s a good indication that they don’t care about their customers’ satisfaction. 

Even if your dog is perfectly healthy and beautiful, many breeders will take back the dog if it doesn’t meet your expectations. This is important to look for in an ethical breeder because it shows they want you to be happy with your new pet.

Are you looking to make better use of your backyard space? Check out our article on how to start landscaping your backyard for tips on how to transform your backyard into a beautiful and functional space that’s perfect for relaxing and enjoying time with family and friends.

What If I Can’t Find A Breeder In My Area?

If you can’t find a breeder in your area, do not buy from a pet store. Pet stores are associated with puppy mills, which are places that mass produce puppies in poor conditions and don’t screen buyers to ensure they will be in good homes. 

Don’t buy from backyard breeders either these folks rarely screen buyers and can often be seen at flea markets or on Craigslist with pictures of their pets on display.

Finally, don’t buy from brokers who buy dogs from multiple sources and resell them. They may have been online for months before you found them because they take advantage of people who want to add a dog to their family but don’t know how or where to start looking for one.

Pros and Cons of Adopting from a Shelter versus Buying from a Reputable Breeder

Pros of adopting from a shelterPros of buying from a reputable breeder
Saves an animal’s lifePurebred animals available
Less expensiveBetter knowledge of the animal’s lineage
Helps reduce animal overpopulationHealth and behavioral screening for parents and offspring
Often includes initial medical carePotential for ongoing support and guidance

Do Reputable Breeders Sell Their Puppies Online?

Buying a puppy online is not a good idea. Reputable breeders do not sell their puppies online because they want to meet their future owners in person and ensure that the dogs are going to good homes. It’s never a good idea to buy a dog from someone who can’t or won’t meet you in person.

If you’re buying from an individual, ask them if they have any children under the age of five years old and how many dogs they’ve had over the past five years (the frequency with which people get rid of their animals should raise red flags). 

If they say yes but refuse to answer any other questions about their past, find another breeder! You don’t want your new dog ending up in someone else’s backyard after just two weeks with his new family.

Should Breeders Have All The Paperwork In Place When I Buy A Puppy?

As a buyer, you’re not just buying the puppy you’re also buying all of its paperwork. If a breeder does not have all of their papers in order, it’s probably not worth your time or money to buy from them. 

The paperwork should be available before any puppies are sold, so if you don’t see it, move on.

If you do see all of the proper paperwork at an early stage in your search and choose to buy from this particular breeder anyway (or start talking with them), then I’d recommend reading through it carefully to ensure that everything is accurate and up-to-date. 

For example: Has this person had all their shots? Are they up-to-date on their rabies vaccinations? Have they been microchipped? Is there an active AKC registration? Do they come from parents who were both healthy themselves without any genetic defects? 

Are both parents registered with OFA (Orthopedic Foundation for Animals)? Check out our article about how much it costs to register a dog from birth through adulthood here!

Responsible Breeders Are The Key To High-Quality Puppy

Responsible breeders have high standards in place to ensure their dogs are healthy, well-tempered, and suitable for breeding. They also make sure their dogs’ genetics will produce puppies with great temperaments and health.

Grass isn’t the only option for your backyard! Check out our article on what you can replace your backyard grass with for alternative options that are easy to maintain and can enhance the beauty of your outdoor space.


If you’re still unsure about the best way to find an ethical breeder, there are plenty of resources available online. The most important thing that you can do is talk to your neighbors and friends who have a dog or know someone who does. 

They can be a wealth of information because they know what kind of care their dog has received, how well-behaved it is in public settings, and whether or not it’s been vaccinated regularly. 

You should also keep an eye out for local rescue groups or shelters that might have puppies available for adoption; they often list their animals on social media sites like Facebook as well as their websites where pet adoptions occur!

Further Reading

Here are some additional articles related to backyard breeding and animals that you may find helpful:

Are Backyard Breeders Illegal? Explained: This article explains the legality of backyard breeding and why it may not be a good idea.

11 Animals That Can Be Raised in the Backyard: If you’re interested in raising animals in your backyard, this article provides a list of options to consider.

Are Backyard Chicken Eggs Safe to Eat?: This article explains the safety of eating eggs from backyard chickens and what to consider.

Are Backyard Chickens Good for the Environment?: Learn about the environmental benefits of raising chickens in your backyard and why it can be a good idea.

Puppy Mills: What They Are and How to Avoid Them – This article provides a comprehensive overview of puppy mills and their connection to backyard breeding, as well as advice on how to avoid supporting these unethical practices.

Signs of a Bad Breeder – This resource outlines the warning signs of a bad breeder, including poor living conditions for animals and lack of proper documentation.

What is a Backyard Breeder? – The RSPCA provides information on what constitutes a backyard breeder and the potential welfare issues that can arise as a result.


Here are some frequently asked questions related to backyard breeding and animal care:

Q: What is backyard breeding?

A: Backyard breeding refers to the breeding of animals, usually dogs or cats, by individuals or small-scale breeders in a non-professional setting, such as a backyard.

Q: Is backyard breeding illegal?

A: Backyard breeding is not necessarily illegal, but it may be regulated by local laws and regulations. It is important to research and understand the laws in your area before engaging in backyard breeding.

Q: Are backyard-bred animals healthy?

A: The health of backyard-bred animals can vary widely. It is important to do research on the breeder and the animal’s parents to ensure they have been properly cared for and do not have any genetic health issues.

Q: What animals can be raised in a backyard setting?

A: Some animals that can be raised in a backyard setting include chickens, ducks, rabbits, and even goats or sheep in some cases. It is important to research the specific needs and requirements of each animal before deciding to raise them.

Q: Are backyard-raised eggs safe to eat?

A: Eggs from backyard-raised chickens can be safe to eat if proper hygiene and care are practiced. It is important to clean and sanitize eggs before consuming them, and to ensure the chickens are healthy and free from disease.